|
|
|
PALESTINE
|
| Sunday, September 11, 2005 | | Saturday, September 10, 2005 |  |  |
Trail of 'targeted
killings,' repeated threats stir suspicions of Israeli hand in Arafat's death Circumstances of Palestinian leader's passing raises question of whether his 'natural'
demise was in fact an assassination by Trish Schuh
Arafat's
Mausoleum, Ramallah, Palestine January 2005
 Editor's note: With recent media reports suggesting that Palestinian
President Yasser Arafat's death may have been the result of foul play, and with theories speculating that the late leader
may have been poisoned or infected with the HIV virus, the question of who is behind the assassination has also been raised.
Suggesting that Israel had the most to gain from Arafat's death, Middle East reporter Trish Schuh has compiled the following
timeline of developments in Israel and the United States leading up to Arafat's death on November 11, 2004. Schuh is
a freelance journalist who has worked for ABC News, Al-Arabiya, Muslim's Weekly, Asia Times, Tehran Times and Counterpunch.
She studied Arabic and Islam at Bir Zeit University in Palestine and observed the 2005 elections in Palestine. | | Yasser Arafat's removal was a triumph for Israel. It fulfilled demands for the election
of anti-Intifada Prime Minister Mahmoud Abbas and his associates who "work well with Israel and America,"
and whose commitment to disarm the Palestinians will enable Israeli land theft for settlements to continue without resistance
or reprisal from undefended Palestinians. Israel achieved Arafat's demise: "The obstacle to
peace will be eradicated forever."
A
Road Map for the End of the Arafat Era According
to President Bush's closest advisors, Bush had a radical change of heart in January 2002, when he
decided for the first time that Yasser Arafat was an irredeemable terrorist unfit as a peace partner. Israel
confiscated the Iranian freighter Karine A in the Red Sea with a cargo of munitions, enroute to Gaza
militants. Upon receiving evidence from the CIA via Mossad that Arafat had knowledge of the shipment, Ariel
Sharon got what he always wanted: America's de facto elimination of Arafat as leader of the Palestinian
Authority. With Washington watching, Israeli tanks surrounded
Arafat's Ramallah compound while Ariel Sharon's cabinet discussed deporting Arafat. Under intense
American and European pressure, Sharon promised Bush not to assassinate him. Middle East Newsline reported
that Secretary of State Colin Powell then approached Egypt, Jordan and Tunisia to provide Arafat safe haven. All refused.
On April 1, 2002, World Tribune.com reported
that Morocco agreed to provide Arafat asylum. After insisting that 70 Hamas and Fatah colleagues accompany
him, the Knesset rejected the proposal, arguing that he would be far more dangerous out of sight, operating a government-in-exile.
A month later, both US Houses of Congress passed resolutions of overwhelming support for Israel and condemning Arafat as
a "terrorist" and a "despot". On June
24th, from the White House Rose Garden, President Bush issued a critical foreign policy shift.
In what analysts deemed "the death knell for Yasser Arafat," Bush publicly called for regime change in
Palestine. He later began to parrot Sharon rhetoric, saying the US would no longer deal with Yasser Arafat,
or acknowledge him as the Palestinians' leader. In the final months of 2002, Israeli experts advised US Justice system lawyers how
to legalize extrajudicial killings. The February 7, 2003 Jewish Forward reported on an unprecedented
legal document developed for the US by Israel. It contained a comprehensive set of justifications for
state terror assassinations, and revealed the Bush administration's involvement in such schemes.
Bush now characterized terrorists caught- but denied rights to trial- as being "otherwise dealt with."
Israeli sources also revealed that Mossad was training the US military and CIA how to implement covert 'hits'
with expertise gained fighting the Palestinians- car bombs, snipers, cell phone explosives, high tech devices and poisoning-
and how to disguise them as "unexplained events and accidents."
Former PFLP official and long time Arafat spokesman, Abu Bassam Sharif, received a letter in December,
2002 from friends in the Israeli peace movement warning of a plot to poison Arafat. (TheGuardian, December
16, 2004) As a step towards regime change, Israel
and the US forced Arafat to appoint Mahmoud Abbas Prime Minister in February, 2003. Abbas's choice for Minister
of State Security, Gazan Mohammed Dahlan was favored by the Bush-Sharon team for his pledge to eliminate Palestinian resistance to
Israeli attacks and settlements. According to the article "US Quietly Backing Anti-Arafat Reform Movement"
in Geostrategy-Direct.com, Americans "worked with" Dahlan to fund and train his thousand
man militia for a coup d état against Arafat by 2005. Arafat biographer Said Aburish noted that torture
of prisoners thrived under Dahlan's rule in the 1990's. Arafat refused Dahlan's appointment.
Abbas resigned in September, 2003 over control of the Palestinian Security Services.
Reacting to increased Palestinian attacks, in August 2003, Israeli Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz
declared "all out war" on the militants whom he vowed "marked for death." In mid September, Israel's
government passed a law to get rid of Arafat. Israel's cabinet for political security affairs declared
it "a decision to remove Arafat as an obstacle to peace." Mofaz threatened; "we will choose the right
way and the right time to kill Arafat." Palestinian Minister Saeb Erekat told CNN he thought Arafat was
the next target. CNN asked Sharon spokesman Ra'anan Gissan if the vote meant expulsion of Arafat.
Gissan clarified; "It doesn't mean that. The Cabinet has today resolved to remove this obstacle. The
time, the method, the ways by which this will take place will be decided separately, and the security services will monitor
the situation and make the recommendation about proper action."
The Jerusalem Post (September 11, 2003) advocated; "We must kill Arafat because the
world leaves us no alternative. When the breaking point arrives, there is no point in taking half measures. If
we are to be condemned in any case, we might as well do it right..." Israeli Deputy Prime Minister Ehud Olmert
said; "We are trying to eleiminate all the heads of terror, and Arafat is one of the heads of terror... Arafat
can no longer be a factor in what happens here. The question is: how are we going to do it? Expulsion is certainly
one of the options, and killing is also one of the options" and "killing Arafat is an open choice for us, definitely
one of the options." Ariel Sharon; "Killing Arafat, more than any other act, would demonstrate that the
tool of terrorism is unacceptable."
Palestinian
Authority Muqata, destroyed by IDF bulldozers
The Israeli Defense Forces Central Command then refined "Operation New Leaf"- code word of the military
operation for Arafat's elimination and its aftermath. Updated repeatedly in the year before his death, the
plan included methods for his killing and burial site, riot prevention, protection of settlements from Palestinian backlash,
and even instructions for IDF soldiers "not to appear too joyful at his death" to avoid provoking grieving
Palestinians. A propaganda plan was also formulated to deprive
Arafat of a hero's status through a non-combat, 'natural' death that would afford the Israelis
plausible deniability. Sharon spokesman Ra'anan Gissan said; "The issue is how to best remove this obstacle
without making him a martyr." IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Ya'alon suggested; "We should kill Arafat
softly....We must kill him softly and throw him out of the PA Presidential Palace and find an alternative leadership.
I'm sure Mohammed Dahlan is qualified for this mission."
In November, 2003, Israel and the US installed new Prime Minister Ahmed Qureia to succeed Abbas.
Qureia also battled Arafat to appoint Dahlan head of Security. By February, 2004 Palestinian legislators discovered
that multimillionaire Qureia's family business, Al Quds Cement, had been selling Israel it's
concrete to build the notorious 'Apartheid Wall'. The UK Telegraph also reported Qureia company
cement mixers making deliveries to the Maaleh Adunim Jewish settlements. In Gaza, cement merchants closely connected
to Qureia through Dahlan reaped exorbitant profits manufacturing cement for Israeli construction projects. Both
men are hailed in Washington as "moderates we can work with."
Qalandiya Watchtower and Checkpoint on The Wall
Responding to a double suicide attack planned in Gaza, Time Magazine reported
that Sharon's security cabinet decided on March 16, 2004 to execute Hamas founder Sheikh Ahmed Yassin
on March 21. Despite world outrage at his assassination, National Security Advisor Condoleeza Rice defended it;
"Let's remember that Hamas is a terrorist organization and that Sheikh Yassin has himself personally, we believe,
been involved in terrorist planning." Arafat
"Marked for Death" Ariel Sharon's
White House visit on April 14, 2004 resulted in a deal with the Bush administration to improve Israel's defense
posture in the Middle East. In exchange for Israel's Gaza pullout, the US agreed to Sharon's
security request- the dismantling of a list of terror threats: Arafat, Nasrallah, Hamas, Hezbollah, and Iranian
nuclear capability. When Sharon presented Bush with proof that Arafat was responsible for the
October 2003 attack on a US convoy in Gaza killing three Americans, Bush finally acceded to Arafat's
targeted removal. Yemen's Foreign Minister
Abubakr Al Qibri warned; "The United States bears responsibility for what happens, since after every visit by Sharon
to Washington he commits more terrorism and more assassinations."
After rescinding his earlier promise to Bush not to harm Arafat, Sharon then branded Arafat a
"legitimate target." "Whoever aims to kill Jews, whoever sends murderers to kill Jews, is 'marked
for death'." He later threatened in the Hebrew daily Yediot Aharonot; "We operated against Ahmed
Yassin and Rantisi and some other murderers at a time that seemed right to us. On the subject of expelling Arafat
we will behave according to the same principle: we will do it at a convenient time. As we behaved toward other murderers
(Yassin and Rantisi), so we will behave toward Arafat."
Ma'ariv then published a terrorist 'deck of cards' from Sharon's
list of those "marked for death." "Everyone is in our sights," said Internal Security Minister
Tsahi Hanegbi, "There is no immunity for anyone. And that means anyone- down to the last person." Lt.
General Moshe Ya'alon added that those on the list "understand it is nearing them." Israeli Foreign Minister
Silvan Shalom also warned that the removal of Arafat was "closer than ever." Former Mossad Chief Ephraim
Halevy had earlier claimed that Yasser Arafat would be out within a year; "Neither he nor Saddam Hussein
are going to live out the year as leader of their countries and their peoples."
In July, 2004 riots protesting Palestinian Authority corruption spread from Gaza to the West Bank
cities of Jenin and Nablus. According to World Tribune.com, Mohammed Dahlan, with US help, had been coordinating
the revolt to strengthen himself as a future successor to Arafat. The powerful lobby, American-Israeli Political
Action Committee (AIPAC) stated; "international pressure coordinated with Palestinian opponents of Arafat’s rule
could accelerate a Palestinian leadership change." (Palestinian sources later claim Dahlan had also directed
an assassination plot against Yasser Arafat's relative, PA military intelligence commander Moussa Arafat. After
his assassination in 2005, Israeli Haaretz says Moussa's killing "strengthens moderates in the PA.")
In the US, a New York Post columnist
quoted an Israeli official at the Republican National Convention in August, 2004; "Arafat will die this year."
The Israeli continued; "I've never steered you wrong about the Middle East before. I know what I'm saying.
Arafat dies this year... Don't ask me more."
On September 6, 2004 Defense Minister Shaul Mofaz reiterated to Israel's Army Radio, the
government's 2003 official decision to end Arafat's reign; "The State of Israel will find the
way and the right time to bring about the removal of Yasser Arafat from the region." Within a month, Arafat had fallen mysteriously ill. From
the first announcement, the American press definitively portrayed Arafat as already dying. In Ramallah, the Palestinian
Authority prevented his personal physician, Dr. Ashraf Al Kurdi, from examining Arafat until it was too late to save
him or get an antidote. Al Kurdi said Arafat knew he was dying; "Yes, actually I heard
from him in Ramallah that he thought he'd been poisoned."
By November 11, 2004 Arafat was dead from undiagnosed causes. After examining his medical
dossier, Arafat's nephew Nasser Al Qidwa claimed Arafat was poisoned. In an interview at his Amman, Jordan office,
Al Kurdi told me: "I suspect Arafat died of a killing poison, a catalyst." Al Kurdi's request
for an autopsy was denied by P.A. officials. (see Al Kurdi interview)
Addressing Al Jazeera, Hamas leader Khaled Meshal declared; "I accuse Israel of having poisoned
the blood of of Abu Ammar." Referring to a 1997 Mossad attempt to poison him, Meshal said; "French
and Arab doctors may not be able to find evidence, as they could not find proof in my blood when I was poisoned, but
Israel was forced to bring an antidote after two of its agents were held in Jordan."
The October 29, 2004 New York Post admitted; "Israel has been preparing for his demise
for months, including his possible burial site." In accordance with the propaganda dictates of Operation New Leaf,
the last public image of Yasser Arafat alive was the antithesis of a national warrior.
Ariel Sharon told Ha'aretz; "It is feared that after his funeral Arafat will become a national hero and
freedom-fighter." The only photo of Arafat not in military
fatigues, the NY Post showed him in pajamas, shriveled, weak, wearing a 'dunce cap'
and looking like a pathetic child. Former Bush speechwriter David Frum (who coined the phrase "Axis
of Evil") utilized a frequent Mossad homosexual slur, asking "Does Yasser Arafat Have AIDS?"
After Arafat
In January, 2005, I requested an interview at the Palestinian Authority Information Ministry,
with the committee investigating Arafat's death. "We have been ordered not to speak of this by our officials
at the highest level." Though Arafat was a world figure for two generations, investigation into his death
has been banned. World governments and media remain largely silent.
As a US official said in 2002; "Arafat's removal will pave the way for the emergence
of moderate leadership" compliant to Israel's security needs. The new Palestinian leadership of
Abbas, Queria and Dahlan are leaders who "work well" with Israel & America, allowing Israeli
land theft for West Bank settlements to continue without 'obstacles'.

|
| The sun never sets on The Wall |
Also published in Mehr News and Muslims
Weekly
| | | |
| Tehran:10:00,2005/04/27
|
| Tehran: 23:34 ,
2005/04/24 |
Print version Email this to a friend | Interview by Trish Schuh | | Arafat's doctor demands answers |
AMMAN (MNA)
-- Dr. Ashraf Al Kurdi was former Palestinian Authority president Yasser Arafat's physician for over 25 years. Freelance
journalist Trish Schuh conducted an interview with him at his office in Amman on January 18, 2005. Following is the
text of the interview: |
| Q: The
U.S. press has insinuated that
Yasser Arafat was a homosexual who died of AIDS. Are you aware of this?
A:
I heard rumors he died of AIDS, but not rumors that he was a homosexual. I have done the HIV tests many times before on Arafat
as a routine test. It was never positive. Q: When was the last time you did a test?
A: About six months before he died. The Tunisian doctors told
me they did this test in Ramallah and it was normal.
Q: Did Arafat have any longstanding health problems?
A: No, apart from the benign, nonessential tremor
which manifests as a tremor in the lips and hands. He never had anything else.
Q: Did he have Parkinson's Disease?
A: Actually, this was investigated many times. No. It was the
tremor only. He was tested many times for Parkinson’s. Q: How long had you been Arafat's primary physician?
A: More
than 25 years.
Q: You treated him after the plane crash in Libya?
A: Yes. We saved his life
from bilateral subdural hematoma. This produced changes in his mental state and his physical appearance. He developed hemoplegia
and when we caught it he was operated on in Amman.
Q: Could this cause any
later medical condition? A: No complications whatsoever. The operation went very smooth and was done by an ordinary
neurosurgeon. Q: Before you saw him the last time, had he had regular checkups? A: Yes, of course.
Q: Arafat complained of stomach pain, could this indicate something?
A: No. He had abdominal pain from time to time, but not constant.
A gastrointestinal gastroscopy showed a mild irritation. Q: In the year prior to his death, how often had you seen him?
A: I was called on the sixteenth day after his
illness, and when I went there I saw a group of Tunisian doctors sent by his wife to Ramallah without calling me. These people
never had any idea about Arafat's health -- never saw Arafat before. I saw four Egyptian doctors and three Palestinian
doctors. After I went to Ramallah with my group, I went straight to see him. There were signs of poisoning, manifested by
a reddish patch on his face and a metallic, yellow color to his skin.
Q:
Did any of these other doctors ask you about his medical history? Have you heard from
them since? A: No, they didn't consult me. Nobody talked to me and none of them knew his health
before, except one of the Egyptians.
Q: Have you been contacted since for your opinion?
A: No. No, there were strict instructions not
to contact me by his wife, according to Palestinian Authority leaders.
Q: How many checkups did he get in the year before his death? A: Three times.
Q:
Was he in good health?
A: Yes, he was perfectly
healthy. But I must stress that I was called officially on the sixteenth day of his illness, not at the beginning, so we can't
know exactly when it started. This is a very important point. I told Suha Arafat that by sending the Tunisian doctors, you
delayed treatment on your husband. A gap of five or six days.
Q: Did you ask the PA leaders about this long delay?
A: There was no good answer -- no one dared to say anything. I was told that Suha refused
me access. Why, I don't know. When I saw him, I decided he must go abroad because there were tests he needed that couldn't
be done in Ramallah. There was contact with the French and their response was immediate. They sent a plane and the Jordanians
sent two helicopters to take him to Amman. Nobody
offered me to go with him to Paris, and whenever
I asked after him, I never got a satisfactory reply. Again, because of one person, probably his wife.
Q: What was his appearance the last time you saw him alive?
A: He lost half of his
body weight. He had this reddish spot covering his face, and his coloring was metallic yellow. He was conscious, talking and
joking, even. His cognitive functions were perfect. After that I asked all the doctors to meet. We concluded he had platelet
deficiency. Some of the causes for this were not clear, so I asked he be transferred to Paris as soon as possible. But even the French doctors didn't ask me for his previous history.
Q: Did Arafat know he was dying?
A: Yes.
Yes, actually I heard from him in Ramallah, that he thought he'd been poisoned.
Q: Did
he say who or why or how? A: No. Q: Last September 25th, 2003, there was an illness that some PA leaders in the Muqata said marked the start of his physical decline.
What do you think?
A: I don't think so, because I went with a team to Ramallah
from Jordan to investigate all known types of poisons.
We took blood samples and there were no poisons, or HIV infection.
Q: According
to Islamic law, when the cause of death is questionable, an autopsy is required?
A: That
is absolutely true. I requested four things: a committee to investigate his health and the progression
of his illness. I wanted all results of the Paris tests and to see the French doctors. I asked for cause of death and if it was not identified to perform an autopsy.
Q: Considering that Yasser Arafat was a major world figure for
half a century, shouldn't an autopsy have been demanded? Why was it denied? Who denied it?
A: All of them. All the leadership, those with him in Paris
and Chairman Mahmoud Abbas. He said there is no need, he is already buried. I said, "It’s
not up to you."
Q: Did you feel
Abbas made the decision alone or was it a committee decision?
A: I don't know.
Q:
When you said publicly you thought he'd been poisoned, did you get threats?
A: No.
The PA said I should communicate this to them, which I had done from the first.
Q: Some
news accounts said the French government would be upset by an autopsy?
A: This is very stupid,
I don't think this would upset them. If someone dies of unknown causes, it is mandatory to have an autopsy -- mandatory!
They know the regulations. Here in Jordan, bodies
have been exhumed many times in criminal cases.
Q: Is there a time limit to exhuming a body to trace forensic
causes?
A: It depends on the agents used. I suspect Arafat died
of a "killing poison", a catalyst. The death was due to this.
| 
Erez Crossing, Gaza 1999 | | | | |
The following
article quotes my interview with Yasser Arafat's doctor word for word, and seems to have had a bearing in the Fatah drive
to exhume Arafat's body. What did Arafat die of?
| Khaled Abu Toameh, THE JERUSALEM POST | May. 14, 2005 |
Members of the ruling Fatah party have launched a campaign on the Internet to collect
one million signatures to demand that the Palestinian Authority launch a thorough investigation into Yasser Arafat's death. Meanwhile, Arafat's private physician, Ashraf al-Kurdi, ruled out the possibility that the Palestinian leader
had died of AIDS, saying a blood test he had conducted showed he was not suffering from the disease. Entitled "Who killed Arafat," the campaign is being launched on one of Fatah's official sites (www.Fateh.tv).
A statement issued by the organizers said their goal was to force the PA leadership to launch a serious investigation to end
the mystery surrounding Arafat's death. Hinting that Arafat may
have been poisoned as part of a conspiracy by some of his aides and foreign parties, the group called for an immediate investigation
into the case. "We want the Palestinian Authority to solve the
mystery surrounding the death of the Prince of the Martyrs," it said. "We want an internal investigation to reveal
if insiders were involved and whether they were aided by foreign parties." They demanded an investigation into why Kurdi was not allowed to accompany Arafat to Paris, where he was treated
in a French military hospital. Moreover, it called for establishing an independent team of specialists to study Arafat's
medical file. Kurdi, a former Jordanian minister of health, accused
Arafat's widow, Suha, of standing behind the decision to bar him from traveling with Arafat to Paris. "There were
strict instructions not to contact me by his wife, according to Palestinian Authority leaders," he told a French journalist. Asked about rumors that Arafat was a homosexual and that he had died of AIDS, the physician said: "I heard rumors
he died of AIDS, but not rumors that he was a homosexual. I have done the HIV tests many times before on Arafat as a routine
test. It was never positive." He said the last time he had conducted
an AIDS test on Arafat was about six months before he died. Dr. Kurdi said that he was permitted
to see Arafat only two weeks after he became ill. "I was told that Suha refused me access. Why, I don't know. When
I saw him, I decided he must go abroad because there were tests he needed that couldn't be done in Ramallah," he
added. "He had lost half of his body weight. He had this reddish
spot covering his face, and his coloring was metallic yellow. He was conscious, talking and joking, even. His cognitive functions
were perfect. After that I asked all the doctors to meet. We concluded he had platelet deficiency. "Some of the causes for this were not clear, so I asked he be transferred to Paris as soon as possible. But
even the French doctors didn't ask me for his previous history." Asked
if Arafat knew he was dying, the physician replied: "Yes. Yes, actually I heard from him in Ramallah, that he thought
he'd been poisoned." Kurdi called for an autopsy to determine
the cause of Arafat's death. "I suspect Arafat died of a 'killing poison,' a catalyst. The death was due
to this," he said. | ALJAZEERA.com
july 12, 2005 | | Fatah chief: Yasser Arafat was poisoned | | 7/12/2005 11:15:00 AM GMT | | 
 The Fatah chairman Faruq Qaddumi contends Yasser Arafat was poisoned.
 |
The head of the Palestinian movement
Fatah asserts that the late Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat was fatally poisoned by Israel. "I can categorically confirm that Abu Ammar (Arafat) was poisoned," exiled Fatah chairman Faruq Qaddumi
told reporters. Arafat, for long the public face of the Palestinian struggle
for statehood, was declared dead in a French military hospital on the outskirts of Paris on November 11 2004 where he had
been treated for two weeks. France's strict medical secrecy laws mean
that the exact cause of Arafat's death has not been made public, but his nephew received a copy of his medical file. Fuelled by the ambiguity surrounding his death, many ordinary Palestinians are convinced that Arafat's death
at the age of 75 was far from natural. Arafat’s personal physician
of more than 20 years, Jordanian Ashraf Al-Kurdi "attests that Abu Ammar presented the symptoms of poisoning," added
Qaddumi, who succeeded Arafat as head of the Fatah movement which the late leader had founded. "The poisoned was administered in the food and in the medication he swallowed," said Qaddumi, who was appointed
Fatah chief after Arafat’s death but refuses to visit the occupied Palestinian territories and lives in Tunis. He further added that the Palestinian health minister Dhehni al-Wahidi, had visited Tunisia to meet with the doctors
there who had examined Arafat prior to his transfer to Paris. Those doctors
had been rushed to Arafat's bedside as his health suddenly plunged in late October 2004, but have since kept their silence
on their findings. A special committee of doctors has been set up to study
the details of Arafat’s medical records after they were handed over to the Palestinian Authority. | | 
What killed Arafat? Infection a mystery | By Steven Erlanger and Lawrence K. Altman The New York Times THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 8, 2005
|
JERUSALEM Yasser Arafat's medical records from the French military hospital where he died in November, which have been held in
secrecy, reveal that he died of a stroke that resulted from a bleeding disorder caused by an unknown infection. A first
independent review of the records, obtained by The New York Times, shows that despite extensive testing, his doctors could
not determine the underlying disease that killed him. But the records dispel one significant and widespread rumor - that Arafat
died of AIDS. The course of his illness and pattern of his symptoms make AIDS highly unlikely, according to independent
experts who have reviewed the records at the request of The Times. They also suggest that poisoning was highly unlikely, although
senior Palestinian officials continue to allege that Arafat, who died Nov. 11 at age 75 after an illness lasting a month,
was indeed poisoned. The records also indicate that Arafat did not receive antibiotics until Oct. 27, or 15 days after
the onset of his illness, which was originally diagnosed as a flu. That was only two days before he was transferred to the
Percy Military Training Hospital in Clamart, outside Paris, and it was probably too late to save him, according to the Israeli
and American medical experts consulted by The Times, who agreed to review the records on condition that they not be identified
by name. The specialists have no prior connection to the case. Arafat's doctors in Ramallah also did not seem to
recognize that he suffered from a serious blood disorder, disseminated intravascular coagulation, or DIC, which was never
controlled and led to his death. Even the French doctors never discovered the specific cause of the infection that resulted
in the bleeding disorder, the records show. "It's a big puzzle," said a specialist in infectious diseases.
No autopsy was performed because Arafat's wife objected to one, The records make no mention of an AIDS test, a deficiency
the experts found curious and even bizarre. An Israeli infectious disease specialist said he would have performed the test,
which is now standard, if only to be thorough and to refute the rumors that surrounded the case. News accounts during
the Palestinian leader's illness made that specialist strongly suspect that Arafat had AIDS, he said. But after studying
the records, the specialist said that AIDS was improbable, given the swift onset of Arafat's intestinal troubles four
hours after eating on the evening of Oct. 12. A senior Palestinian official provided Arafat's medical records to
Avi Isacharoff and Amos Harel, Israeli journalists who are working on a new edition of their book, "The Seventh War:
How We Won and Why We Lost the War With the Palestinians." They agreed to share the records in collaboration with The
Times, which did its own investigation. Arafat's final illness began suddenly when he vomited and had abdominal
pain and watery diarrhea hours after his supper in his compound in Ramallah, where the Israelis had kept him isolated for
three years. These symptoms, including a constant urge to defecate, but without fever, continued for two weeks. He became
stuporous and lost three kilos, or 6.6 pounds. He was treated for thrombocytopenia, an abnormally low platelet count, with
transfusions of platelets and injections of gamma globulin. The Ramallah doctors apparently did not realize that he
was experiencing the bleeding disorder DIC. According to the French records, doctors at the hospital outside Paris did detect
the bleeding disorder. Many senior Palestinian officials have continued to charge that Arafat was poisoned. In a recent
telephone interview from Amman, Arafat's personal doctor, Ashraf al-Kurdi, also said that he believed the Palestinian
leader was poisoned. But the findings argue strongly against poisoning. The French doctors sent specimens to three
laboratories for standard toxicology tests to detect metals and drugs like barbiturates, opiates and amphetamines. None was
detected. The experts said that Arafat did not suffer the extensive kidney and liver damage they would expect from a poison,
although he did have jaundice. Still, one Israeli doctor speculated that a rarer poison like ricin, or even a toxin
produced by cholera, could explain some of Arafat's symptoms and his rapid deterioration. He did improve for a time in
the French hospital, talking and walking with members of his entourage. Then he slipped into a coma on Nov. 3, when
he was transferred to intensive care from the hematology service. That course would seem to contradict the idea of poisoning,
the experts said. The biggest mystery is the exact nature of the infection that seemed to start the prolonged, irreversible
course of the bleeding disorder. The consultants, like the French doctors, could not determine where in the bowel the
infection was located and what microbes caused it. Arafat's doctors in Ramallah provided some clinical information to
the French. Some of the samples taken in Ramallah were sent for analysis to Tunis first, but some biopsies did not arrive
there, the records said. One possibility is a food-borne illness from a toxin produced by staphylococcal bacteria.
The illness occurs commonly from food contamination. Theoretically, someone could have put the toxin in what Arafat ate. But
he did not have some of the features of this type of food-borne illness. The French doctors clearly were baffled by what was
wrong with the frail 75-year-old who had no obvious cause for the infection. By the time he arrived in France, it was
probably too late to save him, the experts said. During his medical care in Ramallah before he went to France, four Egyptian
doctors came, as did five doctors from Tunis, summoned by Arafat's wife, Suha. They did not seem to recognize that he
had DIC and apparently did not start prescribing antibiotics quickly enough, the experts said. The Ramallah doctors
initially thought he had flu. His own physician, Kurdi, was not allowed to come to Ramallah until Oct. 28, the day before
Arafat was evacuated to Paris. The French summary of Arafat's history cites the Faculty of Medicine in Tunis as
saying that cultures of blood, stool, urine and bone marrow were negative, as were tests for cancer and leukemia. It is not
known how long the cultures were in transit from Ramallah and their condition on arrival in Tunis. A stool culture, for example,
would be worthless if it had dried out. The antibiotics given in Ramallah may also have prevented growth in a laboratory culture
of any bacteria that may have caused Arafat's intestinal infection, the consultant experts said. The biopsies performed
in France and Ramallah did not show evidence of any infectious agent or cancer. The bleeding disorder kept the French doctors
from doing some tests they said they would have liked to have done. Although the French doctors also prescribed a number of
antibiotics, Arafat's condition worsened. An American hematology consultant theorized that Arafat may have had
a common infection known as diverticulitis, which develops in outpouchings, known as diverticula, in the large bowel. An infected
diverticula can burst, leaking its contents into the abdominal cavity to cause a localized abscess or an infection like peritonitis.
The French doctors said they did not find this condition, but it can be hard to detect, the consultant said. The consultant
also said that prescribing heparin for Arafat's disseminated intravascular coagulation probably hastened his death, but
that it was inevitable at this stage. American hematologists generally do not recommend heparin for DIC, the specialist said.
Israelis note that Prime Minister Ariel Sharon saw Arafat as a terrorist and an obstacle to peace, and had been on record
as favoring his elimination. In 2002, Sharon told the newspaper Maariv that he regretted not "eliminating" Arafat
in 1982, during the Lebanese war. Arafat's death would have saved many lives, Sharon said, "but we had a commitment"
not to harm him, "and commitments must be honored." He also said then that "we have no intention of
harming Arafat personally." But Uri Dan, a Sharon confidant, wrote in November 2004 that he remembered meetings in 1982
held by Sharon, then defense minister, in his Tel Aviv office "in which he asked the heads of the Mossad when they would
finally carry out Prime Minister Menachem Begin's order to eliminate Arafat." In September 2003, Sharon's
vice prime minister, Ehud Olmert, said of Arafat that "killing him is definitely one of the options." He added:
"We are trying to eliminate all the heads of terror, and Arafat is one of the heads of terror." There have
been reports in the Israeli press of a secret cabinet decision made in late 2003 to eliminate Arafat, which Dan describes
as "a deliberately vaguely worded decision to remove Arafat, since he was an obstacle to peace." Officials have
hinted that operational plans were drawn up to eliminate Arafat, although they say no action |
|
|
| |